A REGULAR TOWN BOARD MEETING WAS HELD ON TUESDAY, JULY 10, 2012 AT THE TOWN HALL COMMENCING AT 7:00 P.M.
PRESENT
DANA HAFF, SUPERVISOR
BARBARA BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN
ELIZABETH FOOTE, COUNCILWOMAN
HENRY GALLINARI, COUNCILMAN
KEVIN MCCARTHY, APPOINTED COUNCILMAN
ALSO PRESENT
DENISE PETTEYS, RMC TOWN CLERK
GREGORY BROWN, HIGHWAY SUPERINTENDENT
MARK MILLER, ENFORCEMENT OFFICER
JOHN HOLMES, PLANNING BOARD
PHIL GIBSON, PLANNING BOARD
RON SMITH, YOUTH COMMISSION
SAM IRWIN, YOUTH COMMISSION
RUSSELL WADE, YOUTH COMMISSION
JIM KEELEY, YOUTH COMMISSION
JEFF MEYER, ATTORNEY FOR THE TOWN
AUDIT
SUPERVISOR HAFF CALLED THE MEETING TO ORDER AT 7:00 P.M.
PLEDGE
A MOMENT OF SILENCE WAS OBSERVED FOR HARTFORD RESIDENT RAYMOND BRINK WHO PASSED AWAY RECENTLY.
PAYMENT OF BILLS
RESOLUTION NO. 12155
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT THE AUTHORIZED BILLS BE PAID ON ABSTRACT #7 OF 2012 IN THE FOLLOWING AMOUNTS:
HIGHWAY VOUCHER #354-377 $173,736.98
YOUTH VOUCHER #378-385 $ 781.20
GENERAL VOUCHER #386-412 $ 6,630.67
SUPERVISOR REPORT
RESOLUTION NO. 12156
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN GALLINARI, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT THE SUPERVISOR REPORT BE ACCEPTED.
TOWN CLERK REPORT
RESOLUTION NO. 12157
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT THE TOWN CLERK REPORT BE ACCEPTED.
MINUTE REVIEW
RESOLUTION NO. 12158
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT THE REGULAR TOWN BOARD MINUTES FOR JUNE 12, 2012 BE ACCEPTED.
JULY 10, 2012 REGULAR MEETING PG. 2 OF 9
RESOLUTION NO. 12159
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT THE PLANNING BOARD MINUTES FOR MAY 23, 2012 BE ACCEPTED.
RESOLUTION NO. 12160
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT THE YOUTH COMMISSION MINUTES FOR JUNE 3, 2012 BE ACCEPTED.
PUBLIC HEARING – MATTISON MOBILE HOME
SUPERVISOR HAFF EXPLAINED THAT THE TOWN BOARD OPENED AND LEFT OPEN THE SCOTT MATTISON/WENDY COLUMBETTI MOBILE HOME PUBLIC HEARING AT THE MAY 8, 2012 MEETING. MARK SAID THAT THEY ARE STILL WAITING FOR THE BANK CLOSING APPROVAL. HE SAID THAT EVERYTHING ELSE IS IN COMPLIANCE. COUNCILMAN GALLINARI ASKED IF MARK HAD THE PAPERWORK FOR A NEW MOBILE HOME. MARK EXPLAINED THAT THEY CANNOT ORDER A NEW HOME UNTIL THE BANK APPROVES THE LOAN. AFTER THAT APPROVAL A NEW HOME TAKES 6 WEEKS TO BUILD AND DELIVER AND HE WILL RECEIVE THE PAPERWORK AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. THERE WAS NO PUBLIC COMMENT.
RESOLUTION NO. 12161
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN GALLINARI, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED TO CLOSE THE MATTISON MOBILE HOME PUBLIC HEARING AT 7:10 P.M.
RESOLUTION NO. 12162
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED TO ACCEPT THE APPLICATION OF SCOTT MATTISON/WENDY COLUMBETTI AND TO ALLOW THE NEW MOBILE HOME ON BALDWIN CORNERS ROAD.
PUBLIC HEARING SUBDIVISION LAW
JEFF MEYER, ATTORNEY FOR THE TOWN CONDUCTED A SEQRA FOR THE PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO SUBDIVISION LAW.
RESOLUTION NO. 12163
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED TO DECLARE A NEGATIVE SEQRA DECLARATION FOR THE AMENDMENTS TO THE SUBDIVISION REGULATIONS.
RESOLUTION NO. 12164
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN GALLINARI, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED TO OPEN AMENDMENTS TO THE SUBDIVISION LAW PUBLIC HEARING AT 7:15 P.M.
THERE WAS NO PUBLIC COMMENT.
RESOLUTION NO. 12165
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN GALLINARI, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED TO CLOSE AMENDMENTS TO THE SUBDIVISION LAW PUBLIC HEARING AT 7:16 P.M.
JULY 10, 2012 REGULAR MEETING PG 3 OF 9
RESOLUTION ADOPTING LOCAL LAW NO. 1 OF 2012 REPEALING LOCAL LAW NO. 1 OF 1997 REGULATING SUBDIVISIONS IN THE TOWN OF HARTFORD
RESOLUTION NO. 12166
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN GALLINARI, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
WHEREAS, THE TOWN SCHEDULED A PUBLIC HEARING TO BE HELD BEFORE THE TOWN BOARD ON JULY 10, 2012 AT 7:00 P.M. AT THE OFFICES OF THE TOWN OF HARTFORD, 165 COUNTY ROUTE 23, HARTFORD, NEW YORK, TO HEAR ALL INTERESTED PARTIES REGARDING THE ADOPTION OF A PROPOSED LOCAL LAW REPEALING LOCAL LAW NO. 1 OF 1997 REGULATING SUBDIVISIONS IN THE TOWN OF HARTFORD; AND
WHEREAS, NOTICE OF SAID PUBLIC HEARING WAS DULY POSTED AND THEN PUBLISHED IN THE POST STAR, THE OFFICIAL NEWSPAPER OF THE TOWN, ON JUNE 15, 2012; AND
WHEREAS, THE TOWN DECLARED THAT THIS ACTION IS AN UNLISTED ACTION UNDER SEQRA, AND DECLARED ITSELF TO BE LEAD AGENCY FOR SEQRA REVIEW OF THE ACTION AND A SHORT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM FOR THIS PROPOSED LOCAL LAW HAS BEEN PREPARED, AND THE TOWN BOARD HAS TAKEN A HARD LOOK AT THE POTENTIAL ADVERSE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS OF THE PROPOSED ACTION AND HAS ISSUED A NEGATIVE DECLARATION IN CONNECTION WITH ITS FINDINGS PURSUANT TO THE STATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY REVIEW ACT (“SEQRA”), AS CODIFIED UNDER 6 NYCRR PART 617 ET. SEQ., RELATIVE TO THE ADOPTION OF THE PROPOSED LOCAL LAW, WHEREBY THE ADOPTION THEREOF CONSTITUTES AN UNLISTED ACTION THAT WILL NOT HAVE ANY SIGNIFICANT ADVERSE IMPACT UPON THE ENVIRONMENT.
WHEREAS, SAID PUBLIC HEARING WAS DULY HELD AND ALL PARTIES IN ATTENDANCE WERE PERMITTED AN OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF OR IN OPPOSITION TO THE PROPOSED LOCAL LAW.
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY THE TOWN BOARD OF THE TOWN AS FOLLOWS:
SECTION 1. THE TOWN BOARD, UPON DUE DELIBERATION OF THE PROPOSED LOCAL LAW FINDS THAT THE ADOPTION OF THE PROPOSED LOCAL LAW SHALL BE IN THE BEST INTERESTS OF THE TOWN.
SECTION 2. THE PROPOSED LOCAL LAW ENTITLED “LOCAL LAW NO. 1 OF 2012 REPEALING LOCAL LAW 1 OF REGULATING SUBDIVISIONS IN THE TOWN OF HARTFORD” IS HEREBY ADOPTED, A COPY OF WHICH IS ATTACHED HERETO AND MADE A PART HEREOF.
SECTION 3. PURSUANT TO AND IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE MUNICIPAL HOME RULE LAW, THE TOWN CLERK IS HEREBY DIRECTED TO ENTER LOCAL LAW NO. 1 OF 2012 INTO THE MINUTES OF THIS MEETING AND FILE THE SAME WITH THE OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF STATE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK.
SECTION 4. THIS RESOLUTION SHALL TAKE EFFECT IMMEDIATELY.
RESOLUTION ADOPTING PROPOSED LOCAL LAW ESTABLISHING THE TOWN OF HARTFORD LAND SUBDIVISION REGULATIONS
RESOLUTION NO. 12167
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
WHEREAS, PURSUANT TO 276 OF TOWN LAW AND SECTION 10 OF MUNICIPAL HOME RULE LAW, THE TOWN BOARD (THE “BOARD”) OF THE TOWN OF HARTFORD (THE “TOWN”) HAS THE AUTHORITY TO ADOPT LOCAL LAWS CONCERNING THE REVIEW OF SUBDIVISION PLATS BY THE TOWN OF HARTFORD PLANNING BOARD; AND
WHEREAS, THE TOWN OF HARTFORD PLANNING BOARD HAS RECOMMENDED TO THE TOWN BOARD THAT THE PROPOSED LOCAL LAW BE ADOPTED BY THE TOWN BOARD; AND
WHEREAS, THE TOWN FINDS AND DETERMINES THAT THIS LOCAL LAW IS NECESSARY TO PROTECT THE HEALTH, SAFETY AND WELFARE OF ITS CITIZENS; AND
WHEREAS, THE TOWN SCHEDULED A PUBLIC HEARING TO BE HELD BEFORE THE TOWN BOARD ON JULY 10, 2012 AT 7:00 P.M. AT THE OFFICES OF THE TOWN OF HARTFORD, 165 COUNTY ROUTE 23, HARTFORD, NEW YORK, TO HEAR ALL INTERESTED PARTIES REGARDING THE ADOPTION OF A PROPOSED LOCAL LAW AMENDING THE TOWN OF HARTFORD LAND SUBDIVISION REGULATIONS; AND
WHEREAS, NOTICE OF SAID PUBLIC HEARING WAS DULY POSTED AND THEN PUBLISHED IN THE POST STAR, THE OFFICIAL NEWSPAPER OF THE TOWN, ON JUNE 15, 2012, PURSUANT TO AND IN CONFORMANCE WITH SECTION 20 OF THE MUNICIPAL HOME RULE LAW; AND
WHEREAS, SAID PUBLIC HEARING WAS DULY HELD AND ALL PARTIES IN ATTENDANCE WERE PERMITTED AN OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF OR IN OPPOSITION TO THE PROPOSED LOCAL LAW; AND
WHEREAS, THE TOWN DECLARED THAT THIS ACTION IS AN UNLISTED ACTION UNDER SEQRA, AND DECLARED ITSELF TO BE LEAD AGENCY FOR SEQRA REVIEW OF THE ACTION AND A SHORT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM FOR THIS PROPOSED LOCAL LAW HAS BEEN PREPARED, AND THE TOWN BOARD HAS TAKEN A HARD
JULY 10, 2012 REGULAR MEETING PG 4 OF 9
LOOK AT THE POTENTIAL ADVERSE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS OF THE PROPOSED ACTION AND HAS ISSUED A NEGATIVE DECLARATION IN CONNECTION WITH ITS FINDINGS PURSUANT TO THE STATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY REVIEW ACT (“SEQRA”), AS CODIFIED UNDER 6 NYCRR PART 617 ET. SEQ., RELATIVE TO THE ADOPTION OF THE PROPOSED LOCAL LAW, WHEREBY THE ADOPTION THEREOF CONSTITUTES AN UNLISTED ACTION THAT WILL NOT HAVE ANY SIGNIFICANT ADVERSE IMPACT UPON THE ENVIRONMENT.
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY THE TOWN BOARD OF THE TOWN OF HARTFORD AS FOLLOWS:
SECTION 1. THE BOARD, UPON DUE DELIBERATION OF THE PROPOSED LOCAL LAW AND THE COMMENTS PRESENTED AT THE PUBLIC HEARING, FINDS THAT THE ADOPTION OF THE SAME SHALL BE IN THE BEST INTERESTS OF THE TOWN.
SECTION 2. THE PROPOSED LOCAL LAW IS HEREBY ADOPTED, COPIES OF WHICH ARE ATTACHED HERETO AND MADE A PART HEREOF. THE LAW SHALL TAKE EFFECT IMMEDIATELY UPON ITS FILING IN THE OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF STATE.
SECTION 3. THE CLERK IS HEREBY INSTRUCTED TO FILE A CERTIFIED COPY OF THE LOCAL LAW WITH THE SECRETARY OF STATE.
SECTION 4. THIS RESOLUTION SHALL TAKE EFFECT IMMEDIATELY.
KNAPP MOBILE HOME
SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT MR. WILLIAM KNAPP IS PROPOSING TO REMOVE A 1967 MOBILE HOME ON COUNTRY LANE EXTENSION AND REPLACE IT WITH A 2000 MOBILE HOME. SUPERVISOR HAFF ADVISED HIM THAT HE NEEDS TO BE IN COMPLIANCE WITH ALL OF THE TOWN OF HARTFORD’S REGULATIONS. BILL SAID THAT HE HAS A MAP OF THE PROPOSED CHANGES HE WANTS TO MAKE TO HIS LOT IN ORDER TO BE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE 1 ACRE REQUIREMENT. SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT HE WILL NEED TO APPEAR BEFORE THE PLANNING BOARD TO DO THE BOUNDARY LINE ADJUSTMENT. COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER SAID THAT ME. KNAPP NEEDS TO HAVE THIS APPROVED AND IT NEEDS TO BE FILED AT THE COUNTY AND THEY WILL NOT COMBINE LAND UNLESS THE TAXES ARE PAID UP TO DATE. SUPERVISOR HAFF ASKED IF THE TOWN BOARD COULD SCHEDULE A PUBLIC HEARING FOR AUGUST. THERE WAS DISCUSSION THAT MR. KNAPP WOULD NEED TO BE APPROVED BY THE PLANNING BOARD AND OBTAIN A BUILDING PERMIT THROUGH THE COUNTY IN ORDER TO BE ABLE TO POUR A NEW CONCRETE PAD FOR THE NEW MOBILE HOME. MARK WAS NOT SURE IF THIS COULD BE ACCOMPLISHED. COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER SAID THAT THE TOWN BOARD SHOULD WAIT UNTIL AUGUST TO SCHEDULE THE PUBLIC HEARING.
SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT MR. KNAPP’S HOME HAS IT’S OWN WELL. THE CONCERN IS THAT HIS DAUGHTER’S HOME DOES NOT HAVE IT’S OWN WELL. MR. KNAPP DID DRILL A WELL AND IT IS CAPPED BUT THERE IS NO PUMP OR DISTRIBUTION PIPING. IT IS ON HIS DAUGHTER’S PROPERTY FOR FUTURE USE. SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THE FACT THAT MR. KNAPP HAS HIS OWN WELL IS FINE FOR HIM; HOWEVER, IN THE FUTURE THERE MAY BE A PROBLEM FOR HIS DAUGHTER – IF SHE WAS TO SELL THE PROPERTY. NO ONE CAN CREATE A LOT THAT IS NOT BUILDABLE THAT CAN HAVE A SEPTIC AND WELL ON IT. SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT THE ATTORNEY FOR THE TOWN RECOMMENDS THE TOWN DRAFT AN AGREEMENT WHEREAS IF THE STATUS OF MR. KNAPP’S DAUGHTER’S HOME CHANGES, IF SHE SELLS HERE HOME OR BRINGS IN A NEWER HOME, THAT MR. KNAPP MUST SEVER THE CONNECTION FROM HIS WELL TO HER HOME. HE SAID THAT WILL BE A REQUIRED CONDITION BEFORE A PUBLIC HEARING CAN BE CLOSED. SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT IF A NEW MOBILE HOME IS BROUGHT IN – IT ELIMINATES THE GRANDFATHER CLAUSE AND THE TOWN DOES NOT ALLOW ANYONE TO RENT MOBILE HOMES.
COUNCILMAN GALLINARI SAID THAT HE FEELS BEFORE ANYTHING IS APPROVED THE BOARD SHOULD HAVE ALL OF THE DOCUMENTATION. THIS ISSUE HAS BEEN GOING ON FOR YEARS. COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER SAID THAT THE TOWN HAS SPENT THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS ON THIS ISSUE AND MR. KNAPP STILL HAS NOT COMPLIED WITH WHAT THE TOWN BOARD ASKED HIM TO DO IN OCTOBER 2006. SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT MR. KNAPP HAS TO BE IN COMPLIANCE WITH OUR LAWS. MARK SAID THAT ACCORDING TO THE OCTOBER 2006 TOWN BOARD REQUIREMENT, HE WAS SUPPOSED TO BE CONTACTED WHEN THE NEW WELL WAS DRILLED AND HOOKED UP TO MR. KNAPP’S DAUGHTERS MOBILE HOME AND IT WAS NEVER COMPLETED. HAVING 2 MOBILE HOMES ON 1 WELL IS NOT IN COMPLIANCE.
SUPERVISOR HAFF ASKED JEFF MEYER, ATTORNEY FOR THE TOWN, SINCE MR. KNAPP HAS A WELL TO HIS HOME – ISN’T IT MORE A PROBLEM FOR HIS DAUGHTER WHO IS SHARING HIS WELL? JEFF SAID THAT THE WAY THE MOBILE HOME LAW IS WRITTEN – BECAUSE THE DAUGHTER DOESN’T HAVE HER OWN WELL – IT ISN’T OKAY AS PREEXISTING. THE FACT THAT HIS WELL IS PUMPING OFF HIS PROPERTY CAN ALSO BE A PROBLEM FOR HIM IN THE FUTURE.
COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER SAID THAT THE TOWN BOARD IS NOT SUPPOSED TO GRANT A PUBLIC HEARING UNTIL THEY FEEL THAT THE APPLICATION IS COMPLETE. MARK MILLER SAID THAT HE THINKS IT IS A GREAT IDEA FOR MR. KNAPP TO REPLACE THE EXISTING MOBILE HOME WITH A NEWER HOME BUT THE PREVIOUS REQUIREMENTS HAVE NEVER BEEN MET. SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT MR. KNAPP HAS TO COME INTO COMPLIANCE WITH THE LAW – SIMPLE AS THAT.
JUNE 10, 2012 REGULAR MEETING PG. 5 OF 9
MR. KNAPP SAID THAT HE DID NOT UNDERSTAND WHY THE LAST TIME THE ACRE REQUIREMENT WAS FILED AT THE COUNTY WHY HE RECEIVED ANOTHER SEPARATE TAX PARCEL OF A SMALL STRIP OF LAND. HE DIDN’T QUESTION IT – NO ONE DID. HE ASSUMED IT WAS TAKEN CARE OF AS AN ACRE OF LAND – HE DIDN’T REALIZE THAT THEY WEREN’T COMBINED INTO 1 PARCEL. COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER DISCUSSED THE 2006 TOWN BOARD DECISION.
INFORMATION
SUPERVISOR HAFF DISCUSSED THE GLAMPING PROPOSAL AT THE OLD FLOYD HARWOOD PROPERTY NOW OWNED BY BOB AND HILARY ORESCHNICK. HE SAID THAT THEY APPEARED BEFORE THE WASHINGTON COUNTY LDC AND THE LDC HAS APPROVED THEM FOR THEIR LOAN PROGRAM WHICH WILL ENABLE THEM TO MOVE FORWARD WITH THIS DEVELOPMENT.
SUPERVISOR HAFF DISCUSSED THE 2012 EQUALIZATION RATE STATUS ISSUED BY NYS OFFICE OF REAL PROPERTY TAX SERVICE AND HARTFORD REMAINS AT 100%.
PLANNING BOARD ALTERNATE RESIGNATION
RESOLUTION NO. 12168
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED TO ACCEPT CHRISTOPHER DEBOLT’S RESIGNATION AS PLANNING BOARD ALTERNATE.
ADVERTISE PLANNING BOARD ALTERNATE VACANCY
RESOLUTION NO. 12169
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN GALLINARI, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED TO ADVERTISE PLANNING BOARD ALTERNATE VACANCY AND APPLICANTS WILL BE ACCEPTED BY NOON FRIDAY, AUGUST 10, 2012 SO THAT LETTERS CAN BE FORWARDED TO THE TOWN BOARD MEMBERS FOR REVIEW PRIOR TO THE AUGUST 14, 2012 MEETING.
TIM SHIELDS COMPLAINT
SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT THE TOWN RECEIVED A NOTICE FROM THE OFFICE OF BREENAN & WHITE, WHO IS REPRESENTING TIM SHIELDS. IT IS A COMPLAINT THAT MR. SHIELDS WAS INAPPROPRIATELY TERMINATED. IT HAS BEEN FORWARDED TO THE ATTORNEY FOR THE TOWN.
COUNTY UPDATE
SUPERVISOR HAFF DISCUSSED A DOCUMENT ISSUED BY WASHINGTON COUNTY THAT SHOWS THE MEDIAN INCOME FOR ALL TOWNS IN THE COUNTY. HE SAID THE TOWN IS RANKED 17TH WITH 4.4% OF INDIVIDUALS AT POVERTY LEVEL.
SCHOOL ATHLETIC FIELD PROJECT UPDATE
SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT HE SENT THE NOI (NOTICE OF INTENT) TO THE STATE. THE STATE DISCUSSED IT WITH JOE DRISCOLL FROM WASHINGTON COUNTY SOIL AND WATER ASKING IF WE INTEND TO PUT ASTRO TURF ON THE PROPERTY. AS SOON AS THE NOI IS APPROVED THEN HE PLANS TO COORDINATE WITH THE SCHOOL TO SCHEDULE A GROUND BREAKING CEREMONY.
NYMIR ANDREWS WELL
SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT THE MORRIS ANDREWS SALT PILE WELL WATER CONTAMINATION COMPLAINT WAS SUBMITTED TO THE TOWN’S INSURANCE CARRIER – NYMIR. THE ATTORNEY FOR THE TOWN REQUIRED THE TOWN SUBMIT THE CLAIM TO THE INSURANCE COMPANY TO MAKE SURE THAT THEY WOULD NOT INDEMNIFY THE TOWN AND PAY THE CLAIM. THEY HAVE RESPONDED THAT WILL NOT INDEMNIFY THE TOWN AND WE DO NOT HAVE ANY COVERAGE FOR THIS – SHOULD WE BE DEEMED GUILTY. THIS NOW ALLOWS THE ATTORNEY TO REPRESENT THE TOWN AND MOVE FORWARD. THEY WILL HAVE THE ANDREWS’ COME IN AND BE INTERVIEWED SOMETIME IN AUGUST.
FLOOD PLAIN PERMIT FORM
SUPERVISOR HAFF ASKED MARK HOW HE WAS PROGRESSING WITH CREATING A FLOOD PLAIN PERMIT FORM. MARK SAID HE IS STILL WORKING ON IT AND SUPERVISOR HAFF ASKED THAT HE HAVE SOMETHING PREPARED FOR THE AUGUST MEETING.
JULY 10, 2012 REGULAR MEETING PG. 6 OF 9
WASHINGTON COUNTY SHERIFF DEPT LIAISON PROGRAM
SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT HE HAS BEEN IN CONTACT WITH THE WASHINGTON COUNTY SHERIFF DEPARTMENT TOWN LIAISON, CORY HURLBURT REGARDING THE SHATTUCK’S STRAY HORSE ISSUE. HE SAID THAT THEY SHOULD DEFINITELY CALL AND COMPLAIN ABOUT HORSES IN THE ROADWAY – THE SHERIFF WILL HAVE TO RESPOND. AND AFTER SO MANY COMPLAINTS – THE SHERIFF’S OFFICE WILL CONTACT THE DISTRICT ATTORNEY TO REQUEST A CRIMINAL NUISANCE CHARGE.
TRUCK BIDS
SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT THERE WAS 1 RESPONSE TO THE TRUCK BID SOLICITATION. THE BID WAS OPENED ON JULY 6 AND COPIES WERE MAILED OUT TO THE TOWN BOARD TO REVIEW. THE BID CAME IN AT $72,895 AND SUPERVISOR HAFF, JOEL CARPENTER, SUPERVISOR CLERK AND GREG BROWN, HIGHWAY SUPERINTENDENT REVIEWED THE BUDGET TO DETERMINE WHERE THE MONEY WOULD COME FROM SHOULD THE TOWN BOARD DECIDE TO ACCEPT THE BID.
RESOLUTION NO. 12170
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN GALLINARI, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED TO ACCEPT BID FOR $72,895 FROM DELUREY SALES & SERVICE FOR A USED 2005 INTERNATIONAL MODEL 7600 6 X 4 TANDEM AXLE TRUCK WITH COMBINATION DUMP BODY/SANDER, PLOW, WING AND ALL NECESSARY HYDRAULICS AND ATTACHMENTS.
RESOLUTION NO. 12171
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN GALLINARI, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING BUDGET AMENDMENTS TO PURCHASE THE TRUCK:
H203 HIGHWAY EQUIP CAPITAL – $34,827.00
D5031.0 INTERFUND TRANSFER – $34,827.00
D2662.0 HIGHWAY – SALE OF EQUIPMENT -$ 3,115.00
D2701.0 REFUND OF PRIOR YEAR EXPENDITURE -$ 835.00
D1000.0 REAPPROPRIATION +$30,816.00
D5130.2 HIGHWAY – MACH EQUIP PURCHASES +$69,593.00
RESOLUTION NO. 12172
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT THE 1997 SINGLE AXLE INTERNATIONAL DUMP TRUCK BE DECLARED SURPLUS.
RESOLUTION NO. 12173
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED TO ADVERTISE FOR BIDS ON THE 1997 SINGLE AXLE INTERNATIONAL DUMP TRUCK.
ELDRIDGE LANE UPDATE
SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT HE RECEIVED A LETTER FROM ROBERT WINN WITH A COPY OF A REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL INTERVENTION THAT WAS FILED WITH THE WASHINGTON COUNTY CLERK’S OFFICE REQUESTING A PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE IN THE MATTER FILED AGAINST THE COUNTY. THE PURPOSE OF A REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE IS TWO-FOLD: 1) TO ASCERTAIN IF A FRAMEWORK CAN BE ESTABLISHED IN ORDER TO REACH A SETTLEMENT OF THE CASE; AND 2) IF A FRAMEWORK FOR A SETTLEMENT OF THE CASE CANNOT BE ESTABLISHED, TO ASCERTAIN WHAT FURTHER DISCOVERY THE COUNTY FEELS THEY WOULD NEED PRIOR TO A SUMMARY JUDGMENT MOTION BEING FILED ON THIS CASE.
APPOINT YOUTH COMMISSION MEMBER
SUPERVISOR HAFF READ THE APPLICATIONS FOR APPOINTMENT AS YOUTH COMMISSION MEMBERS IN THE ORDER THAT THEY WERE RECEIVED – JIM KEELEY, JENNIFER NIMS AND MICHAEL MULHALL.
JULY 10, 2012 REGULAR MEETING PG. 7 OF 9
RESOLUTION NO. 12174
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN GALLINARI, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT JIM KEELEY BE APPOINTED AS FULL TIME MEMBER OF THE YOUTH COMMISSION.
RESOLUTION NO. 12175
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT JENNIFER NIMS BE APPOINTED AS FULL TIME MEMBER OF THE YOUTH COMMISSION.
RESOLUTION NO. 12176
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN GALLINARI, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT JIM KEELEY’S APPOINTMENT WILL FILL LONGER TERM VACANCY THROUGH 12/31/17 AND JENNIFER NIMS WILL FILL TERM VACANCY THROUGH 12/31/13.
POST YOUTH COMMISSION ALTERNATE MEMBER VACANCIES
RESOLUTION NO. 12177
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED TO ADVERTISE 2 YOUTH COMMISSION ALTERNATE VACANCIES AND APPLICANTS WILL BE ACCEPTED BY NOON FRIDAY, AUGUST 10, 2012 SO THAT LETTERS CAN BE FORWARDED TO THE TOWN BOARD MEMBERS FOR REVIEW PRIOR TO THE AUGUST 14, 2012 MEETING.
TOWN WIDE GARAGE SALES
SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT HE HAS BEEN IN CONTACT WITH LOO’S ON THE LOT FOR PRICING FOR 2 PORT-A-POTTIES FOR THE TOWN WIDE GARAGE SALE. HE SAID THAT HE CONTACTED STEWART’S AND WHAT’S COOKING TO RECOMMEND THEY STOCK UP ON BREAKFAST SANDWICH’S FOR THE EVENT.
RESOLUTION NO. 12178
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN GALLINARI, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED TO SPEND $150 FOR PORT-A-POTTIES FOR THE TOWN WIDE GARAGE SALE TO BE HELD AUGUST 11 & 12, 2012.
YOUTH COMMISSION REPORT
RON SMITH DISCUSSED A LETTER THAT THE YOUTH COMMISSION RECEIVED FROM THOMAS ABRAHAM IN RECOGNITION FOR WORK THAT HAS ALREADY BEEN COMPLETED ON VARIOUS FIELDS AT THE SCHOOL. RON DISCUSSED THE SOFTBALL/BASEBALL SEASONS AND THE EFFORTS OF THE COACHES. HE DISCUSSED THAT THEY HOPE TO RECOUP SOME OF THE SHIRT MONEY THAT WAS AN ISSUE THIS YEAR BY REUSING SOME SHIRTS IN THE FUTURE. HE DISCUSSED SOME ITEMS THAT HE LEARNED AT A PHILOSOPHY OF COACHES CLINIC.
RESOLUTION NO. 12179
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT THE YOUTH COMMISSION REPORT BE ACCEPTED.
HARTFORD VOLUNTEER FIRE COMPANY REPORT
KEVIN MCCARTHY REPORTED THE CALLS FOR THE 2ND QUARTER OF 2012. HE SAID THAT THE DRIVEWAY PAVING IS ALMOST COMPLETED.
RESOLUTION NO. 12180
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT THE HARTFORD VOLUNTEER FIRE COMPANY REPORT BE ACCEPTED.
JULY 10, 2012 REGULAR MEETING PG. 8 OF 9
HIGHWAY SUPERINTENDENT REPORT
GREG BROWN SAID JEFF CHAPIN IS BACK TO WORK AND FEELING GOOD. HE SAID THAT THE MOWER HAS BEEN HAVING SOME ISSUES AND THEY ARE TRYING TO GET IT BACK TOGETHER AND MOWING THE ROADSIDES AGAIN SOON. SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT GREG WANTS TO ADD AN ADDITIONAL $15,000 TO THE CHIPS PAVING ACCOUNT.
RESOLUTION NO. 12181
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN GALLINARI, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED TO ACCEPT THE FOLLOWING EXTRA CHIPS MONEY BUDGET AMENDMENTS AS FOLLOWS:
D5142.4 SNOW REMOVAL – CONT EXP PURCHASES -$ 10,000.00
D1000.0 RE-APPROPRIATION +$ 5,000.00
D5112.2 HIGHWAYS – (CHIPS) PERM IMPR +$15,000.00
RESOLUTION NO. 12182
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT THE HIGHWAY SUPERINTENDENT REPORT BE ACCEPTED.
ENFORCEMENT OFFICER REPORT
MARK MILLER DISTRIBUTED A JOB “TRACKING FORM” THAT HE PREPARED. THERE WAS DISCUSSION REGARDING THE FORM AND HE WILL REVISE IT. MARK SAID THAT HE CONTACTED BILL MCFARREN – THE HOUSE NEAR THE GOLF COURSE – HE IS WORKING ON GETTING IT CLEANED UP. MARK SPOKE WITH THE NEW OWNER OF THE MOBILE HOME ON ROJCEWICZ LANE – HE STILL NEEDS TO INSTALL A GROUND NUT AND CONDUIT FOR HIS ELECTRICAL INSPECTION. A TREATMENT WAS DONE ON THE WELL AND HOPEFULLY THAT WILL TAKE CARE OF THE WELL WATER. HE IS STILL WORKING ON INSTALLING THE HOLD DOWNS AS WELL. MARK SAID THAT HE TALKED TO JEFF MEYER REGARDING JARED EVANS AND HE IS PUTTING A NEW METAL ROOF ON THE HOME. MARK SAID THAT HE HAS BEEN ALLOWING JARED TO CONTINUE THE IMPROVEMENTS TO SEE HOW FAR HE GETS BEFORE PROCEEDING FURTHER. SUPERVISOR HAFF SAID THAT HE DOES NOT UNDERSTAND WHAT SERVING LEGAL PAPERS DOES. MARK SAID THAT BY SERVING HIM IT IS GIVING HIM 30 DAYS TO ATTEMPT TO COMPLY – IF HE DOES NOT START TO COMPLY – THEN IT CAN PROCEED TO COURT AND CAN BE CHARGED FOR EVERY DAY NOT IN COMPLIANCE. MARK SAID THAT HE BELIEVES HE IS ATTEMPTING TO COMPLY. MARK SAID THAT HE INSPECTED THE NEW MOBILE HOME THAT BILL KNAPP WOULD LIKE TO BRING IN AND IT IS IN REALLY GOOD SHAPE. THERE WAS FURTHER DISCUSSION REGARDING THE SITUATION.
RESOLUTION NO. 12183
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN GALLINARI, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT THE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER REPORT BE ACCEPTED.
PLANNING BOARD REPORT
JOHN HOLMES ASKED IF MIKE SWEZEY HAD CONTACTED MARK REGARDING A DRIVEWAY ON BLOOD STREET. HE SAID THAT THERE ARE ISSUES WITH SAFETY REGARDING THE DRIVEWAY ACCESS AND SOMEONE LIVING IN A CAMPER UP THERE. THERE WAS DISCUSSION REGARDING MANY CAMPERS AROUND TOWN THAT NEED TO BE INVESTIGATED.
RESOLUTION NO. 12184
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN GALLINARI, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT THE PLANNING BOARD REPORT BE ACCEPTED.
DCO REPORT
SUPERVISOR HAFF REVIEWED THE DOG CONTROL REPORT. THERE WAS DISCUSSION REGARDING PIT BULLS RUNNING IN MORNINGSIDE CEMETERY.
RESOLUTION NO. 12185
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT THE DCO REPORT BE ACCEPTED.
JULY 10, 2012 REGULAR MEETING PG. 9 OF 9
COURT REPORT
SUPERVISOR HAFF SUMMARIZED THE COURT REPORT.
RESOLUTION NO. 12186
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY, THE FOLLOWING RESOLUTION WAS ADOPTED 5 AYES, 0 NAYS. VOTING AYE, SUPERVISOR HAFF, COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER, COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE, COUNCILMAN GALLINARI AND COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY.
RESOLVED THAT THE COURT REPORT BE ACCEPTED.
ON MOTION OF SUPERVISOR HAFF, 2ND BY COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER THE MEETING WAS ADJOURNED AT 8:55 P.M.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED, _____________________________DENISE PETTEYS, RMC TOWN CLERK
______________________________ __________________________________
SUPERVISOR HAFF COUNCILWOMAN BEECHER
______________________________ __________________________________
COUNCILWOMAN FOOTE COUNCILMAN GALLINARI
____________________________
COUNCILMAN MCCARTHY